R417A refrigerant is widely described as a greener replacement for R22. That description is wrong, and the error matters if you are specifying or servicing equipment.
R417A has a global warming potential of 2,346 on the IPCC Fourth Assessment basis used by current regulation. R22, the refrigerant it replaced, sits at 1,810. On the older Second Assessment basis the figures are roughly 1,950 and 1,700. Whichever assessment report you use, R417A has a higher GWP than R22.
So R417A was never a climate improvement. It was something more specific and more useful: a drop-in retrofit gas that let an existing R22 system keep running after R22 was banned, without replacing the compressor oil. That is a real engineering achievement and it is why hundreds of thousands of systems are still running on it. It is also why R417A is now a legacy service gas rather than a forward choice.
This article covers what R417A actually is, where the published GWP figures diverge and why, the trade-offs that came with the retrofit, and what to do when a system running it reaches the end of its life.
Composition and Properties
R417A, also sold as ISCEON MO59, is a three-component blend:
| Property | R417A |
| Composition by mass | R125 46.6%, R134a 50%, R600 3.4% |
| GWP (IPCC AR4) | 2,346 |
| ODP | Zero |
| ASHRAE safety class | A1, low toxicity, no flame propagation |
| Temperature glide | Approximately 5 °C |
| Oil compatibility | Mineral oil, alkylbenzene and POE |
| Cooling capacity | Lower than R22 |
Two of those rows deserve attention before anything else.
The A1 classification is worth stating plainly because R417A contains 3.4 percent R600, n-butane, which on its own is a flammable A3 hydrocarbon. At that concentration the blend does not propagate flame and is classified A1. R417A is not a mildly flammable refrigerant. Guidance that treats it as one, or that groups it with A2L fluids, is incorrect.
The 5 °C glide is where the practical consequences live, and it gets left out of most descriptions. More on that below.
Why Published GWP Figures Disagree
You will find R417A quoted at 1,950 in some places and 2,346 in others, and both numbers are defensible. The difference is which IPCC assessment report the component GWPs come from.
The Second Assessment Report gives R125 a GWP of 2,800 and R134a 1,300. Weighted by the blend, that produces roughly 1,950. The Fourth Assessment Report revised those to 3,500 and 1,430, which produces 2,346.
This is not academic. The EU F-Gas Regulation and the US AIM Act both use AR4 values, so 2,346 is the figure that governs compliance, quota accounting and documentation. If a datasheet quotes 1,950, it is working from a superseded basis.
The same applies to R22: 1,700 on the SAR basis, 1,810 on AR4. Any comparison has to use one basis consistently, and once it does, R417A comes out higher than R22 either way.
So Why Was R417A Ever Specified?
Because R22 was removed for a completely different reason than climate.
R22 is an HCFC. It contains chlorine, and it carries an ozone depletion potential of 0.055. The Montreal Protocol targeted it on that basis, and the phase-out was about the ozone layer, not about global warming. R417A has an ODP of zero, which satisfied the regulation that was actually in force.
The second reason is the one that made R417A commercially successful, and it is purely practical. It works with the mineral oil already in the system.
An R22 compressor runs on mineral oil or alkylbenzene. The obvious alternatives at the time, R410A and R407C, require polyolester oil and will not circulate mineral oil reliably. Converting to either meant flushing the system, changing the oil, often changing the compressor, and in many cases the economics did not work on a unit with eight years of life left.
R417A circulates with mineral oil, alkylbenzene and POE. That turned a system rebuild into a recovery, a charge and a performance check. For a building owner facing a fleet of R22 rooftop units, that difference was the whole decision.
So the honest summary: R417A solved an ozone problem and an oil problem. It did not solve a climate problem, and it was never marketed accurately on that point.
The Trade-Offs That Came With It
A retrofit gas chosen for compatibility rather than performance carries costs, and three of them show up in service work.
Lower cooling capacity than R22. This is the one that produces complaints. On a system with design margin, the loss is absorbed. On a system already working at its limit, it shows up as longer run times, slower pull-down, and a space that no longer quite reaches setpoint on the hottest days. The equipment is not faulty; it is doing less work per kilogram of refrigerant than it was designed to.
Lower discharge temperature. Genuinely a benefit. The compressor runs cooler, which reduces thermal stress and oil degradation, and on an ageing compressor that matters. Worth noting alongside the capacity loss rather than instead of it.
Temperature glide of around 5 °C. This is the one that changes how you work on the system:
- Charge as a liquid, always. Charging as vapour draws off the more volatile components preferentially and shifts the blend ratio in the cylinder and in the system. The performance you measure afterwards is not the performance of R417A.
- Measure superheat and subcooling against the correct reference. With glide, there is no single saturation temperature. Superheat is referenced to the dew point and subcooling to the bubble point. Using one number for both gives readings that are wrong in opposite directions.
- After a leak, recover and recharge rather than top up. A leak changes the composition of what remains, so adding fresh gas to a partially leaked charge gives you a blend that is not R417A and does not perform like it. Topping up a glide blend is a shortcut that produces a system nobody can diagnose afterwards.
Find and fix the leak first. Our overview of HVAC leak detection methods compares the available approaches, and HVAC tools and equipment covers the gauges and recovery kit.
Where R417A Still Appears
R417A was specified for medium temperature direct expansion duty, which in practice means:
- Stationary air conditioning originally built for R22. Split systems, rooftop packaged units, and chillers in commercial buildings.
- Medium temperature commercial refrigeration. Display cabinets, cold rooms and cellar cooling.
- Some heat pump water heaters of that generation.
What those applications have in common is their age. R22 production ended in the European Union in 2010 for virgin gas and 2015 for reclaimed, and in the United States on 1 January 2020. Any system retrofitted to R417A was already in service before those dates, which makes the installed base somewhere between fifteen and twenty-five years old today.
That is the context for every R417A decision now. The question is rarely whether to keep running on it. It is whether the equipment it serves is worth another repair.
Is R417A Still Legal?
Yes, with a caveat that is about cost rather than prohibition.
Under the EU F-Gas Regulation, the ban on using virgin HFCs for servicing applies at a GWP of 2,500 and above. R417A at 2,346 sits just below that threshold, so virgin R417A remains available for servicing existing equipment. By comparison, R422D at 2,729 is above the line.
That margin is thinner than it looks. The HFC quota, which caps how much HFC can be placed on the EU market measured in CO2 equivalent, falls to 24.3 percent of the 2015 baseline for 2025 and 2026, then 12.3 percent for 2027 to 2029. Because the quota is denominated in CO2 equivalent, a high-GWP fluid consumes it disproportionately: one kilogram of R417A eats three and a half times the quota of one kilogram of R32 for the same job. Suppliers allocate quota to the fluids that stretch furthest.
So the practical forecast is not a ban date. It is rising price and thinning availability, with reclaimed gas becoming the main supply route. Plan a recharge on an R417A system to cost noticeably more each year.
What Replaces R417A Equipment
A current-generation Legom heat pump running on R32
There is no low-GWP drop-in for R417A, and that is the point. A retrofit gas exists to extend the life of equipment designed around a banned refrigerant. Once that equipment reaches end of life, the replacement is new equipment designed around a current fluid, not another retrofit.
The realistic options depend on the application:
- R32, GWP 675, A2L. The mainstream choice for splits, ductless systems and air to water heat pumps.
- R-454B, GWP 466, A2L. Dominant in US ducted residential, because its operating pressures sit close to R410A and simplified the equipment redesign.
- R290, propane, GWP 3, A3. Excellent properties, restricted to applications where the charge stays small and outdoors, which suits monobloc heat pumps.
- R513A, GWP 631, A1. Relevant where a non-flammable fluid is required, typically in chillers and some commercial refrigeration.
For context on the fluid that sat between R417A and today, our page on R410A and its phase-down covers the middle generation and the compliance dates now in force.
One point that matters more than the refrigerant choice on a heat pump installation: the flow temperature the system is designed around. A unit producing 35 °C water for underfloor heating operates far more efficiently than the same unit producing 55 °C for radiators, often by 20 percent or more of COP. See why air to water heat pumps are efficient.
Handling and Storage
Nothing exotic, but the glide changes two habits.
Store cylinders upright in a cool, dry, well-ventilated place, out of direct sunlight and away from heat sources. Pressure rises with temperature, and a cylinder left in the sun is a cylinder working against its own relief setting. Secure them for transport so they cannot fall or be struck.
Then the two blend-specific rules, which bear repeating because they are the ones that get skipped: charge as a liquid, and after any loss of charge, recover and recharge rather than topping up.
Recovered R417A goes to a licensed reclaimer. Because reclaimed gas is becoming the main supply route for legacy fluids, recovering properly is no longer only a compliance obligation; it is what keeps the material available for the next system that needs it.
Legom Heat Pumps and HVAC Components
Jiaxing Legom Technology Co., Ltd. manufactures air to water heat pumps and HVAC control components from our facility in Jiaxing, Zhejiang, supplying more than 90 countries.
Our heat pump range runs on R32 across the line in 5 kW, 6 kW, 9 kW and 16 kW capacities. Our note on the R32 heat pump and GWP covers the refrigerant decision from the equipment side, and types of heat pumps covers the configurations.
Documentation is issued per model rather than per range, because the refrigerant charge, the GWP and the Ecodesign figures differ between capacities, and F-Gas and AIM Act paperwork is checked against the specific model. For importers, the relevant tariff classifications are set out in our guide to HS codes for HVAC products.
Alongside the heat pumps we manufacture the hydronic side of the system, including HVAC and safety valves and the controls. For buyers specifying to their own brand, our OEM and ODM service covers the full package. Tell us the destination market alongside the capacity and we will confirm the documentation position before quoting.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the GWP of R417A?
2,346 on the IPCC Fourth Assessment basis, which is what the EU F-Gas Regulation and the US AIM Act use. Older sources quote around 1,950, which comes from the superseded Second Assessment values. Use 2,346 for anything compliance related.
Is R417A better for the environment than R22?
Only on ozone. R417A has zero ozone depletion potential where R22 has 0.055, which is why R22 was phased out under the Montreal Protocol. On climate, R417A is worse: 2,346 against R22 at 1,810 on the same basis. It was never a low-GWP refrigerant.
What is R417A made of?
R125 at 46.6 percent, R134a at 50 percent and R600 at 3.4 percent by mass. Despite the hydrocarbon component, the blend is classified ASHRAE A1, meaning low toxicity with no flame propagation.
Can I use R417A to retrofit an R22 system?
That is what it was designed for, and its advantage over R410A and R407C is that it circulates with the mineral oil already in the system rather than requiring a change to POE. Expect a measurable reduction in cooling capacity, which matters on a system that had little design margin to begin with.
Is R417A banned?
No. The EU ban on virgin HFCs for servicing applies at GWP 2,500 and above, and R417A at 2,346 is below that line. What is tightening is supply: the HFC quota is measured in CO2 equivalent, so high-GWP fluids consume it quickly and suppliers favour the fluids that stretch further. Expect price and availability pressure rather than a ban date.
Why does my system perform worse after an R417A retrofit?
R417A has lower cooling capacity than R22. On a system with design margin the loss is absorbed; on one already at its limit it appears as longer run times and slower pull-down. The equipment is not faulty, it is doing less work per kilogram of refrigerant than it was designed around.
Can I top up an R417A system after a leak?
It is poor practice. With around 5 °C of glide, a leak changes the composition of the remaining charge, so adding fresh gas produces a blend that is not R417A. Find the leak, recover the charge, and recharge with liquid to the correct weight.
What replaces R417A?
Nothing, as a drop-in. A retrofit gas exists to extend the life of equipment built for a banned refrigerant, so once that equipment is finished the replacement is new equipment on a current fluid: R32 for splits and air to water heat pumps, R-454B for US ducted residential, R290 for monoblocs, or R513A where a non-flammable fluid is required.
“R417A gets sold as the green option and it is nothing of the kind. Its global warming potential is higher than the R22 it replaced, and anyone comparing the two honestly reaches that conclusion in a minute. What it genuinely did was let an owner keep a working system running without changing the compressor oil, at a point when the alternative was replacing the whole machine. That was worth a great deal in 2012. In 2026 the equipment it saved is twenty years old, and the right question is no longer which gas goes in, it is whether the unit is worth another repair.”
— Maggie Shen, Director of Legom
Reviewed by Maggie Shen, Director at Legom, on October 9, 2026. This article was reviewed for technical and regulatory accuracy, including the verified R417A composition and GWP of 2,346 on the IPCC AR4 basis, the comparison against R22 at 1,810, the ASHRAE A1 classification despite the R600 component, the approximately 5 °C temperature glide and its charging and diagnostic implications, oil compatibility as the basis for the retrofit, and the EU F-Gas 2,500 servicing threshold and quota phase-down steps.